The Denver school board voted 4-2 Thursday evening to appoint Caron Blanke to serve as the central Denver board representative until the November 2027 election.
Blanke, who came in second among four candidates in the District 3 race in 2025, won support from board members Monica Hunter, Amy Klein Molk (both backed during the 2025 campaign by the Denver Classroom Teachers Association), John Youngquist, and Kimberlee Sia (backed by Denver Families for Public Schools.
Board President Xóchitl Gaytán (DCTA-backed) and Marlene De La Rosa (Denver Families-backed) voted against Blanke’s appointment.
So can we finally put to rest the tired old narrative about union versus reformers? It coukd come roaring back as the 2027 campaign heats up, but let’s hope not.
Co-hosts Alan Gottlieb and Alexis Menocal Harrigan discuss today’s vote and its ramifications on this very brief episode.
Episode transcript:
Alan Gottlieb: [00:00:00] Hi, everybody. We are doing a special edition of the podcast this evening, which is Tuesday, November 19th, shortly after the vote of the Denver School Board to make Karen Blank the one-year representative, or director, from District 3, following the resignation several weeks ago of DJ Torres. This is a very interesting development and vote, so we just wanted to spend a few minutes talking about the current state of the Denver School Board and Denver Public Schools in light of this.
Alan Gottlieb: One thing I just wanted to say right at the outset, and then I’ll have Alexis give her thoughts, is I think let’s finally put to rest once and for all this narrative that there are two sides, and one is the Denver Classroom Teachers Association and one is people who were backed by Denver Families for Public Schools. [00:01:00] That may have been true once. It may have even in some ways been true in the last election. But if you look at the vote to name Karen the new board member, the vote was four to two, with the four voting for Karen including two people backed by Denver Families, John Youngquist and Kimberlee Sia, and two backed by the Denver Classroom Teachers Association, Amy Klein Molk and Monica Hunter.
Alan Gottlieb: And the two people voting against naming Karen were Xóchitl Gaytán, the board president, who’s also backed by the DCTA, and Marlene De La Rosa, who was backed by Denver Families. So the alliances, the allegiances, everything has changed, and it’s really based on personal relationships, beliefs in particular directions the district needs to go in, and no loyalty or allegiance to one or the other interest group, or whatever you wanna call it. And this is healthy, 100% healthy. So I’m encouraged by what happened today, [00:02:00] both because I think Karen will be an excellent board member, but also because it’s just time to move past that tired old narrative.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Yeah, that was pretty great. I completely agree, Alan. I was in the audience, and it’s hard being in the audience because you have to keep your face pretty straight during it, and that wasn’t always the case. But just to back up a little bit, we had some really strong public testimony from different individuals.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: I was particularly impressed with Veronica Figoli’s speakers. And Veronica made a point… Sorry, I have a newly adopted dog that is very interested in what is going on on the podcast. So everybody, meet Landy, AKA Landis dog. She’s curious about what’s going on here. We just went on a walk, and you’ve been fed, and you’ve gotten treats, so I need you to go away now.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: So I was there in person, and Veronica Figoli’s speakers were incredibly impressive. It was unfortunate that the Spanish-speaking parent wasn’t able… the [00:03:00] system didn’t work for her, and Veronica called that out. And it was too bad. And I frankly don’t think the translation, or I’m sorry, the interpretation, was that great, and I’m so sorry to the interpreters. I normally think that they do a really nice job, but because of the snafu, their interpretation didn’t fully capture the remarks. I am saying that as a Spanish speaker myself.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: And then we had an incredible young woman, Brielle Burkett, who spoke, who’s an East High School student. And congrats to Brielle. She just won her DECA competition category last night and also had lacrosse practice.
Alan Gottlieb: What’s DECA?
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Oh, that is a great question. It’s the business club that students…
Alan Gottlieb: Oh, right. That’s right.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Yeah, it’s like the business club. Sorry, everybody, my ADHD brain is ADHD-ing hard right now. So public comments went really well. What was fascinating, going back to your comment, Alan, about the lines being blurred, the divisions have been broken. The person that most of us have believed is supported by the [00:04:00] DCTA, who is Barclay Jones, his speaker was arguably one of the people you would assume to be Reform, because it was Miguel In Suk Lovato, who is somebody I have known since high school, because he went to East.
Alan Gottlieb: I’ve known him for 20 years too.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Yeah. One of the great human beings in Denver. I have tremendous respect for Miguel. Miguel also happens to be one of the original advisory board members of this podcast, of BoardHawk, and worked for the Daniels Fund for a very large portion of his career, and now works for the Donnell-Kay Foundation, which is also perceived to be a Reform entity. So the lines are blurred. All rules are off, and we’re in a new era, everyone.
Alan Gottlieb: Yeah, and I think, a couple of thoughts. One is that all three of the finalists were really, I thought, pretty strong. Kudos to the board, because there were other good people, but the three finalists they named were really strong, all three of them, and I thought they all acquitted themselves pretty well during this session today where they were asked questions. It was interesting to me, because clearly Karen and Barclay were reading their answers. [00:05:00] They wrote them out, to really make sure they had their thoughts fully captured. Veronica seemed to be a little more off-the-cuff but did a good job as well, and she was also remote. It looked like she was in a hotel room somewhere.
Alan Gottlieb: But just to burst another bubble, there’s been a lot of talk about everything that happened around Monica Hunter and her censure, which again kind of had two parts to it: all the bogus stuff that Gaytán and Marrero brought forth about her, and then the more real stuff about things she either said to or allegedly about Amy Klein Molk. But then Monica today voted for Karen Blank, who is Jewish, is a member of a conservative synagogue in Denver, very active in the Jewish community. So Monica didn’t hesitate to vote for her. I think that’s just another interesting little tidbit to consider. So it was an encouraging day.
Alan Gottlieb: I don’t know how I would be feeling right now if I were either the board president, Xóchitl Gaytán, or the superintendent, Alex [00:06:00] Marrero, about the composition of the board. But I think Karen and the rest of them are pretty fair-minded people, so we’ll just see where things go from here.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Yep, agreed. A couple other things I want to mention. The way that this came about was after the interviews and public comment, and if everybody can hear the dog, the motion moved in very quick, short order. John Youngquist made the motion, and I actually wasn’t sure how things were gonna go down because, the way that the order goes, Marlene voted first. She said no. Then Xóchitl Gaytán…
Alan Gottlieb: Well, wait, before we go into the vote, I’m sorry, I don’t wanna… But I think what’s fascinating is that John made the motion, and I can’t remember who seconded it. Maybe you do?
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Oh, who seconded the motion? I think it was Amy.
Alan Gottlieb: Okay. And then Xóchitl Gaytán, the board president, said, “Does anybody wanna have any conversation or [00:07:00] discussion about this?” And there was a long silence, and then she said, “Mr. Youngquist, do you want to perhaps elaborate on why you did this?” And he said, “No, I think I’ll defer to my colleagues,” and nobody said anything. So there was a nomination, a second, no discussion, vote, boom, over.
Alan Gottlieb: A lot of people were gaming out scenarios where there were gonna be multiple rounds of voting. When Charmaine Lindsay got named, somebody said recently that there were, like, nine rounds of voting before she got appointed.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Correct.
Alan Gottlieb: So this was quick and really pretty gratifying. And given that Xóchitl wouldn’t allow for a bathroom break, that was probably one reason they wanted to get out of there.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: I think that’s the ungenerous interpretation. President Gaytán would not allow for any breaks, and I thought that was a choice, and I think that choice was because she didn’t want to allow for any delay. Well, how do I say this? If there was no coordination ahead of time… I think it’s illegal for there to be [00:08:00] coordination during the meeting. And so the generous version, and I’m just gonna say the generous version, I’m not gonna go negative, is that President Gaytán didn’t want there to be any break in state statute or in rules where there’s coordination during the meeting during a break.
Alan Gottlieb: Like they step out in the halls and whisper to each other.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Exactly. And that’s part of the reason I went out into the hall. So what happened was John called for a break, and Marlene was already out of the room, but they did have quorum. Melissa McCall, or Lori Atwood, who’s the board liaison, wasn’t there. She was also taking a break. So two people were already out of the room, I’m assuming taking a break: Secretary Marlene De La Rosa and then the board liaison.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: So John made a motion to take a break. The motion failed, with only Monica Hunter seconding. So he just walked out to say, “I am taking a break.” And then President Gaytán made a comment, “Well, we still have quorum, so we’re gonna keep going.” And then Monica said, “I also have to take a break.” And because I knew [00:09:00] that it’s illegal to do coordination, I went into the hallway to make sure those two weren’t talking, and they weren’t. They went separate ways and weren’t communicating. And Monica had a little coughing fit. I could hear her around the corner.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: But it was really interesting, and that’s why I think he did what he did: “Well, if you don’t wanna take breaks, let’s just move this through very quickly.” And a little bit as, I don’t know, a jab at Sochi. So the no discussion was interesting.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: But what I do wanna say is I think Karen has been doing the work, and I think Karen has spoken with every board member. She has been showing up. She has provided receipts. She has been doing this even before she chose to put her name in for the vacancy. I was sharing with a friend on my way home that you really see somebody’s character after they lose, and particularly after they lose an election. And as somebody who has lost an election and chose to kind of go into hiding from the Denver community for about two [00:10:00] years and came back after my wounds had healed, Karen, after losing, didn’t skip a beat.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: She got very involved, very engaged. She had already been engaged, but I think much more publicly, because her profile was raised. And I think that showed up in how well-prepared she was. She had a leg up because she had been so involved, and she just did a phenomenal job. I also think, to your point earlier, everybody answered the questions really well.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: I do not know Barclay, and I think he seems like a great guy. He had really impressive answers. I was on my phone looking things up, and he was talking about targeted universalism, and I’m a big fan of that framework, and he had some really emotional and really powerful responses. But I think at the end of the day, Karen’s just been showing up and doing the work consistently.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: And unfortunately, Veronica got pegged as the reformer. What’s interesting is she was pegged as the reformer for the last couple of weeks, but then in the last 24 hours, some people have been posting on social media saying Karen’s the reformer. So I don’t know who the [00:11:00] reformer is anymore, and here we are again.
Alan Gottlieb: Well, let’s get away from that. Exactly. That narrative is just tired.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Yeah, it’s BS.
Alan Gottlieb: Well, one just quick comment about the whole bathroom break thing. I was thinking back, and this is probably before your time, Alexis, but there was this big kind of cult-like self-help movement back in the ’70s and ’80s called EST. Erhard Sensitivity Training is what I think it stood for, a guy named Werner Erhard, and it was this cult-like self-improvement thing. They really tried to break people down. It was, like, multiple-day workshops that people went to, out of town, and paid a lot of money for.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Where are you going with this, Alan?
Alan Gottlieb: And they would not let you go to the bathroom. You had to just hold it all day, is the legend at least about them. Not that I ever… God knows I never even thought about doing it.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Now we may need to add hydration, snacks, and adult diapers to the list for board meetings, because that’s how it’s gonna go moving forward. Yeah, I just, I don’t know what to say about that. That’s weird. What else?
Alan Gottlieb: I don’t know. I don’t think we have a lot more. I think basically [00:12:00] the outcome is the outcome, and it’s a positive one from my perspective. I think it’s gonna be interesting to see where the board goes from here. The ideal thing that you hope to see now is that they hit the ground running and actually do some work and stop the internal bickering and fighting. But I think if Xóchitl continues to try and strong-arm the agenda and not work collaboratively with her colleagues, it’s not gonna turn out well for her, because I don’t think Karen will give any more quarter than DJ Torres did to misbehavior by the board president. So we’ll see.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Yep, I agree. We’ll see how this board works together. And I really appreciate how you started this, Alan. I think the old divides are gone, and it’s really exciting that we’re in this new era.
Alan Gottlieb: We don’t know what’ll happen when the next election comes around a year from now, and whether some organization rises up again to try and challenge the DCTA’s organizing might, and then they start talking about this divide again. But I would really love to see that put behind us, because I actually think it doesn’t help move forward [00:13:00] the district or the future of the kids of Denver to be continually bickering. And again, it’s like we’re all bickering within a very narrow band, too. It’s not like we have Christian nationalists and huge voucher advocates on one side pitted against Democratic socialists on the other. Denver’s a very liberal town, and we’re basically arguing from center left to far left, and it’s just not that big a gap. So why don’t we just knock it off and try and figure out how to get work done?
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Yep. And speaking of center left and far left, I would just wanna add one thing as a point of personal privilege. I spoke two nights ago on behalf of Vice President Monica Hunter at the Denver Democratic Party executive committee meeting. I don’t know that I’ve ever said this publicly on the podcast, but I disagreed with the censure vote, and I did speak on her behalf at the Denver Dems’ executive committee, which passed a resolution asking the school board to rescind her censure. So that, I think, is just another [00:14:00] layer to the complexity of the school board and the politics.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: And I just also wanna add, as a point of privilege here, that having been a longtime member of the party, I don’t agree that the Denver Democratic Party should be engaging in partisan school board governing and elections. That being said, my support of Black women, and Monica in particular, who I believe was treated unfairly and not given due process, outweighed my principled stance that the Denver Dems shouldn’t be getting involved in Dem-on-Dem races. But they’ve opened up this can of worms. And huge kudos to Mickael Parker, who used that opportunity to stand in support of Black women. So again, point of personal privilege. Alan and I probably disagree on this one, but I just wanted to share that personally.
Alan Gottlieb: Well, we might have to disagree, so I’ll take my point of personal privilege to say that the school board should never have censured her for the whole array of things they censured her for, because a lot of it was, well, perhaps somewhat concerning… and I’m separating out deliberately here the antisemitic remarks [00:15:00] part. But the other things that were ginned up by the board president and the superintendent should never have been voted on, and she should never have been censured for those things. It’s as bogus in my mind as the censure of John Youngquist a year before that.
Alan Gottlieb: I do think that some of the comments she made directly to Amy Klein Molk, her fellow board member, are troubling and were certainly deserving of, if not a censure, a stern talking-to, and maybe a censure. But they diluted the effectiveness of the censure overall by lumping it all together and voting on it, so I think that’s unfortunate. So that’s where we differ, and that’s where we agree.
Alexis Menocal Harrigan: Well said, yeah. Well, thank you all for listening to the podcast. More to come soon, and I’m sure we’ll have much more to talk about in the coming weeks. And if folks don’t hear from us before the Thanksgiving break, I hope you enjoy your Thanksgiving, and everybody be safe.
Alan Gottlieb: That’s right. All right, take care, everybody. Thanks so much. Bye.



